Meles Zenawi: A dove of peace and a military strategist II
(By Sani Awol 02/11/13)
" Every day of peace is more valuable to us than anyone else. Don't
take it as bragging, but every single peaceful day has more worth to
These were the words Meles Zenawi spoke during his first press
conference following the aggression by Eritrea in 1998.
When citizens were angered by the violation of their sovereignty and
when politicians were rushing for cheap popularity, Meles Zenawi was
one of the few voices of reason who reminded the nation the cost of
Meles knew better than to be swayed by emotion. He knows his duty is
to lead the people not taking populist positions for personal
ambitions. Thus, even though Meles knew that his patriotism was being
questioned in the private press, he didn't pander for cheap popularity
in his first press conference following the aggression.
Instead, he assertively said:
"we have shown our manhood(warrior-skill) for centuries. We had enough
of it. Our priority is the battle with poverty. We can't spare a day
from this battle. Every day of peace is more valuable to us than
anyone else. Don't take it as bragging, but every single peaceful day
has more worth to us"
Obviously, Meles more than anyone else was angered by President Isaias
Afeworki's madness. Eritrea's aggression was in clear contradiction of
what the two governments' have been discussing for several years. It
was an attack against his leadership, against his home land, against
his party and above all against his beloved country.
Nonetheless, he saw every single day of war will drain the nation's
treasury, workforce and other resources. It will also make a heavy
military buildup necessary, as the veteran TPLF fighters had been
In the mid-1990s, with the official establishment of the national
defense forces, almost 40,000 TPLF fighters were demobilized for the
sake of balancing ethnic composition. Therefore, the only way to bring
ethnic representation in the army, without making it too large, was
retiring part of the existing army.
Moreover, everyone at the time believed Ethiopia has no real military
threat from its neighbors. Even the opposition camp spiritual father
Proff. Mesfin Woldemariam wrote in his book "in 1995 that "the only
purpose of an army is too oppress the citizens as none of the
neighboring countries will dare to invade Ethiopia. Therefore, we
should only have a police force."
Meles was not that much idealist but he believed in building a small,
effective and cost-efficient army that would not be a burden to the
economy. In consequence, tens of thousands fighters trained and
experienced by Meles's doctrine of war were demobilized and returned
to civilian life.
The nation was slowly building a heterogeneous, competent army
spending less than 4% of the GDP. The nation's GDP growth was
averaging about 7-8% per year. War would reverse all this.
Meles was worried about all that and wished to avoid war. But that was
not because he didn't care or didn't know about war. As August 1998
telegram of US Embassy Addis Ababa, published by Wikileaks, summary of
Meles's discussion with US diplomats shows, his position was firm. He
With the invasion of Badme and the attempt to change facts on the
ground by force, Eritrea crossed an Ethiopian red line. On other
issues, Ethiopia might have agreed to turn its cheek, but this affront
was so great that to let it pass in silence would have been
essentially to relinquish national sovereignty. Thus, the demand that
Isaias withdraw and that Badme be returned to the status quo ante is
everything. If he does, then perhaps he will have learned his lesson.
If he does not, then he must be taught.
what is important is that the invader withdraw before the invaded.
Eritrea has to do this unilaterally, not as its side of a joint
withdrawal for demilitarization. That will make the point to all
Eritreans that there can be no change by force, and they will act as a
brake on Isaias should he wish to go adventuring again. That will be
Ethiopia's guarantee of security in future.
It was not mere rhetoric. When war became inevitable, Meles the
military strategist came out.
He visited battle areas and army barracks without making it a public
By analyzing the first round of battles, he developed a researched
guide for the war, including how battles should be coordinated and
executed and what the role of each level of commander should be.
He developed four strategic documents. He personally prepared the
first two key and detailed documents, on "depth operation" and on "the
use of force". He also outlined the contents of two other smaller
documents, which were prepared by his officials. He also gave
orientation for the field commanders who successfully executed the
documents and achieved a historic victory against the Eritrean army
which has been preparing for a decade.
Once our sovereignty was restored, Meles didn't hesitate for peace
despite calls for adventurism from some sections. Having restored
sovereignty and with Eritrea signing a humiliating treaty to
demilitarize 25 kilometer deep from the border and be patrolled by
international peacekeeping troops until all outstanding matters are
resolved, Meles was eager to return to economic building and improving
the life of Ethiopians.
However, Meles didn't neglect the national defense forces. He resumed
his effort to build a small, effective and cost-efficient army that
would not be a burden to the economy.
Meles prepared a policy document "Revolutionary democracy and Defense
capacity building" and trained the army officers and relevant
officials. He consistently followed-up the army's recruitment,
promotion and logistical and operational capabilities.
Therefore, when the so-called Union of Islamic Courts controlled most
of Somalia and started declared jihad in Ethiopia, the national
defense forces were well-prepared to deal with them.
However, Meles was not in rush to show his military power rather he
gave peace a chance. He sent his officials to from London to Qatar and
other places about 5 times for a peace talk with the UIC officials. He
went as far as inviting them to Addis Ababa, but they declined as it
would be 'recognizing' Ethiopia - a country they vowed to punish. In
fact, they considered the peace overtures as a fear on Ethiopian side.
Even the Americans were worried that Ethiopia could be defeated. As
the December 2006 Wikileaks cable state:
"In five meetings with Prime Minister Meles and separate meetings with
Foreign Minister Seyoum and ENDF Chief of Staff General Samora during
the week of November 27, the Ambassador and U.S. visitors, including
General Abizaid and Senator Feingold, raised the need for Ethiopia to
be cautious in taking any action in Somalia."
However, as much as Meles efforted for peace, he was not going to
bargain on Ethiopia's security intersts and he knew he built a
reliable army. As the same cable recorded:
"Meles noted to us that his forces will "take their time," carefully
analyzing the situation in Somalia. However, he told us that UIC
attacks on the Transitional Federal Government (TFG) in Baidoa would
prompt an immediate reaction by Ethiopia in defense of the TFG."
When the UIC crossed the red line, Meles ordered a military assault at
once. The defence forces built under Mele's guidance and his military
doctrine flushed UIC troops from Mogadishu in a few days and captured
Kismayu less than two weeks after the start the military operation.
The effectiveness of Meles's military doctrine could be better
appreciated when we compare it how the Kenyan army struggled to
capture Kismayu last year.
Following the astonishing success in Somalia, Ethiopia's military
capacity became undisputable by any knowledgeable security analyst.
However, Meles never turned his back to peace efforts even with minor
trouble makers, such as the OLF and ONLF. He encouraged local elders,
diplomats and others to bring the groups to peace talks.
When the ONLF killed more than 70 oil workers including Chinese
citizens, Meles once again returned to his usual scientific guidance
of military power. He developed a researched counter-insurgency manual
that made ONLF almost non-existent in the region. An achievement
exemplary even for army's of rich countries equipped with state of the
art technologies. Still, Meles never stopped his effort to bring the
remnants of ONLF to peace until his last days.
What is most impressive about all this is that such an effective force
was built with a total annual budget of less that 2% of the GDP, while
the nation's economy was growing.
This is a prove of the wisdom of Meles's military doctrine that sums
up both his commitment for peace and his insight as a military
strategist. As he wrote in Ethiopia's Foreign and Nationals security
"It must be clear that the primary objective of building up our
defense capacity is that of deterrence. Efforts must be deployed to
further the development of democracy, and not war. Our objective is to
prosper, and not to achieve a state of military arrogance. We should
go beyond conflict and engage in war for one and only one reason -
when conditions are imposed that block our path to democracy and
development,and negotiations yield no result. If faced with such a
war, our objective is to emerge victorious with as limited an impact
as possible on the national economy."